Can the Association’s Documents be Contradictory and Still Enforceable?

A recent New York Court dealt with an issue on leasing (Olszewski v. Cannon Point Association, Inc., 148 A.D.3d 1306 (2017)).  The Board adopted rules and regulations that placed restrictions on leasing that contradicted relevant portions of the Association’s Bylaws.  The Association then fined the owner for violating these restrictions and the owner sued.  The owner won at the circuit court level and the Association appealed.  On appeal, the Court again ruled in favor of the owner, upholding the trial court’s decision.  Why?

The Bylaws stated in relevant part that: “any home may be conveyed or leased by its … owner free of any restrictions” provided the owner is current with his assessments. Even though the Bylaws gave the Board the authority to pass rules and regulations as they saw fit, it did not give the Board the authority to contradict a provision already in the Bylaws.

Associations need to be aware of the priority given to each of the governing documents and to make sure these documents work together in order to avoid situations like this New York case. The small amount it will cost to have that review done at the front end could save your Association thousands of  dollars later on.

If you have any questions, please feel free to contact us.

 

Categories

Three bars icon gold

Recent blog Posts

Three bars icon gold

Michelle Polly-Murphy Named Partner at Kaman & Cusimano!

Kaman & Cusimano is proud to announce that Michelle Polly-Murphy has been named a Partner ...
Read More →

Jillian Henzler Named Partner at Kaman & Cusimano!

We are proud to announce that Jill Henzler has been named a Partner at Kaman ...
Read More →

Ohio Senator Introduces Legislation with Drastic Government Overreach Into Community Association Operations

On September 29, 2026, Senator Brenner introduced Senate Bill 476, which proposes significant changes to ...
Read More →

Why Is Preventive Maintenance One of Your Association’s Most Important Investments?

When budgets tighten, it can be tempting for associations to delay maintenance projects. After all, ...
Read More →