Chapter 13 Bankruptcy – Can the Association’s Lien for Unpaid Assessments be Stripped Off? YES

In New Jersey, the United Stated Bankruptcy Court held in In re. Smiley, 569 B.R. 377 (2017) that a Unit Owner/Debtor can modify the Association’s lien and strip off all but the six month super lien allowed under the state’s condominium act.  The facts at the time were that the Association was owed $9,000 for filed liens and another $4,700 that it recognized as unsecured.  At the time of the bankruptcy filing, the monthly assessment was $250.  The fair market value of the property according to the bankruptcy schedules was $142,000, but it was under water because of a $174,000 first mortgage on the property.  Based on these facts the Unit Owner/Debtor claimed, and the court found, that despite the proper lien filings, the Association only had security for $1,500 ($250 x 6 months).

Lesson.  Don’t wait to file and foreclose your liens.  Start the process in 90 days, including timely filing all liens, and then foreclose when it makes sense (normally immediately for a condominium and in year two for a homeowners association).  If you don’t, the bankruptcy courts are not going to protect you and your Association will lose even more, because it will be stuck with an owner who is not paying for even longer.

Categories

Three bars icon gold

Recent blog Posts

Three bars icon gold

Why Is Preventive Maintenance One of Your Association’s Most Important Investments?

When budgets tighten, it can be tempting for associations to delay maintenance projects. After all, ...
Read More →

K&C Partner, Scott Weiss quoted in Wall Street Journal

Before purchasing a home in an HOA or condo association, it’s important to look beyond ...
Read More →

Kaman & Cusimano Attorneys recognized by the Best Lawyers in America®

Kaman & Cusimano is proud to announce that 8 K&C lawyers have been recognized in ...
Read More →

Can Contractors Add Fuel Surcharges to Community Association Invoices?

In recent months, nationwide fuel prices have increased dramatically.  Condominium and homeowners’ associations are increasingly ...
Read More →